A BAFTA hosted talk on narrative design in videogames

This is a repost from earlier in the year, without the automatic and obnoxious bolding that Squarespace loves to include.

“There’s likely to be standing room only,” the eager man told me as I arrived for the BAFTA hosted talk on narrative design in videogames. And why wouldn’t there be? The panel was as close to rock stardom as we get in the industry; Ian Livingstone (Co-creator of Games Workshop), Andrzej Sapkowski (Author of The Witcher series), Meg Jayanth (Writer and Digital Producer of 80 Days), Chris Gardiner (Narrative Director at Failbetter Games) all hosted by Simon Parkin (Journalist for The New Yorker and The Guardian).

Simon, Ian, Chris, Meg and Andrzej.

Simon, Ian, Chris, Meg and Andrzej.

After shuffling in and grabbing an extremely blurry photograph (“It’s so when I write about it later I have a picture to put in the post!” I told my ever-patient girlfriend) we settled in for a series of questions about the nature of narrative design and the challenges that those on the stage, and indeed beyond it, face daily.

For those unaware Chris, Meg and Ian work in branching narratives; Sunless Sea, 80 Days and the Fighting Fantasy book series comprise tens of thousands of words, many of which players will never see. And that’s Simon’s initial question; is there a preciousness about the words you write? Is there ever a storyline so good, a chunk of text so beautiful, that you’re disappointed it’s never seen?

The answer, as if professionally rehearsed, is a resounding “no,” but it’s a far cry from being a typical ‘PR’ style answer. Instead it’s the honest assessment of talented people who have seen thousands of words left on the cutting room floor across their careers. As someone who can barely drop words from a sentence (no matter how superfluous) it was an eye-opening, refreshing response.

The talk drifts between topics like how AAA gaming is taking narrative more seriously, how critics can often be unfair when discussing narrative (a particularly fascinating answer from Chris Gardiner the highlight, though Simon Parkin’s not so subtle allusion to Rock, Paper, Shotgun’s Mass Effect: Andromeda piece a close second), and the best practice for writing, in practical terms, from each of the panel.

The late night, candle at both end burners and the early morning coffee shop clichés were in; but it’s fascinating to see, though not unsurprising, how dedicated and driven these talented people are. “I can’t have anyone around me,” says Livingstone, “it’s door closed, blinds drawn and head down.” This is a man, of course, who created Games Workshop, wrote the Fighting Fantasy series and had a hand (to say the least) in several successful videogames; but nothing fell by the wayside. “Games Workshop 9-5, Fighting Fantasy 9-2am,” as envy and awe swept across the room, not least from a man who can barely handle a game of Overwatch after work without getting tired.

The two key questions in the talk are addressed towards the end, in between Simon Parkin trying manfully to keep Mr Sapkowski on topic; how AAA gaming is evolving and how criticism isn’t. Meg Jayanth, aside from her work on 80 Days and an upcoming title, also worked as a writer on the mega hit Horizon: Zero Dawn. The game, aside from being a staggeringly beautiful work of open world AAA goodness, has been praised for the lore, world building and characterisation. “Games these days, even the AAA titles, have to have an engaging narrative,” says Livingstone, “there’s so many games now, so much competition for our time and attention, that studios seem to be realising just how important a compelling story is.”

Gameplay is still king, a sentiment held across the panel, but games are now being pulled up for subpar stories and narrative. A sign of a maturing medium, but is it also a sign of maturing criticism around it? (It’s not without a hint of disappointment I write that, knowing full well the torrent of abuse hurled at a female developer on Mass Effect: Andromeda this week.) The answer should be yes to both, but, as Christ Gardiner eloquently suggests, criticism has stood still.

“Games,” he suggests, “have such a broad audience.” He doesn’t just mean in terms of demographics, but also in how each of us consumes games. He suggests that the games studios are making have to work for all types of players – people who play two hours then come back months later and pick up where they left off, or people who finish your game in one sitting, or people who slowly consume your game over 6 months. Criticism, he argues, doesn’t account for that.

It’s a question I wish I’d put to Simon Parkin; how does criticism grow and develop in the face of things like branching narratives? How does it move to address Gardiner’s concerns? How do you offer criticism on the story of a game if you happened to experience a branch that was slightly weaker than one of your friends? It’s a question that has, I suspect, a long answer, saved for another Parkin hosted panel.

The talk felt short, though that’s a compliment on how engaging both the topic and the speakers were and, as ever, the assembled huddle left with more questions than we came in with.

The panel piqued my interest in becoming more involved in this community; attending more talks, reading more broadly in and around the medium and meeting like minded people. Next stop: Ken Levine’s keynote at EGX Rezzed.

 

Interview: Oozi and Steam Greenlight

Interview: Oozi and Steam Greenlight

One of the aims I had in mind for Coffee Break Gaming is to be a place for people to talk about their projects; their podcasts, their art, their game or their website. This is the first part in that project. An interview with one of the creators of Oozi: Earth Adventure on the development, completion and subsequent frustrations that they’ve faced in the project.

Interview : Demigod

Interview : Demigod

A lot of games out there are excellent. The problem lies when some of them get overlooked for reasons beyond their control or through horrific consumer tastes! I’m shining the spotlight on some overlook gems starting with Demigod. I chatted with Bert Bingham (Associate Producer on Demigod), now of Wargaming, about the project from its inception to its troubled launch and beyond.

Interview: Shattered Horizon

Interview: Shattered Horizon

Shattered Horizon, the sci-fi FPS from Futuremark, was a game I saw a lot of in the run up to, and post, release. A beautiful game that took simple gameplay mechanics and, with clever use of gravity and fully three dimensional environments, looked set to revolutionise the landscape. Fast forward four years and Shattered Horizon has mere dozens of active players, with Futuremark having bowed out of game development with their studios now owned by Angry Bird creators Rovio Entertainment.

Interview: Only If

Only If isn’t a special game. I played through it in a few hours and, aside from one or two severe issues, thought it was ok, reviewed it and moved on. There was something about the game that stuck with me though; was it the confusing sequences? Was it the bits I hated? Was it the bits I liked? I wasn’t sure, but I emailed Tarek Ghandour, developer on Only If, to pick his brain about Only If and some of the ideas behind it.

Terra Nova: Strike Force Centauri Interview – Dan Schmidt

Terra Nova: Strike Force Centauri Interview – Dan Schmidt

In 1996, I stood staring at a box in the local game emporium, slotted between fare like Amok, Duke Nukem 3D and Star Wars: Dark Forces. It was Terra Nova: Strike Force Centauri. A critical success, a commercial failure and one of influential developer Looking Glass Technologies’ most intriguing one-offs. Eighteen years have passed since this science-fiction mech game was released and it still remains a formative gaming experience. While many rightly remember Looking Glass for their work on the Ultima Underworld series, the System Shock and Thief games, this hard-fought technological masterpiece deserves a second look.